Book 14 of my 2025 Reading Challenge
read from January 26 - 31
I Will Do Better: A Father's Memoir of Heartbreak, Parenting, and Love
by Charles Bock
published 2024
Summary (via the book jacket)
The novelist Charlie Bock was a reluctant parent, tagging along for the ride of fatherhood, obsessed primarily with his dream of a writing career. But when his daughter Lily was six months old, his wife, Diana, was diagnosed with a complex form of leukemia. Two and a half years later, when all treatments and therapies had been exhausted, Bock found himself a widower - devastated, drowning in medical bills, and saddled with a daunting responsibility. He had to nurture Lily and, somehow, maybe even heal himself.
I Will Do Better is his pull-no-punches account of what happens next. Playdates, music classes, temper tantrums, oh-so-cool babysitters, first days at school, family reunions, single-parent dating, and a crippling city-wide natural disaster were minefields especially treacherous for Charles and Lily because of their preexisting vulnerability: their grief. Charles sought help from friends, family, and therapists, but this overgrown middle-aged boy-man and this plucky child became, foremost, a duo - they found their way together.
My Opinion
2 stars
For marketing purposes, I added this book to my 'to-read' list after seeing it in People Magazine.
Reviews of memoirs make me uncomfortable, especially if I'm skewing negative. But I start with the caveat that I'm not judging the experiences themselves, I'm judging the way they were written about which is something the author can expect after publishing a book.
Sooo...this was a tough read. I expected it to be tough based on the subject matter but it was tough for other reasons instead. Although he was incredibly incredibly honest on his negative feelings there wasn't a balance of positive feelings/redemption. I'm not expecting him to magically change fundamental personality traits but the title of the book is I Will Do Better...does he feel he did (and still is as Lily was 13 at the time of publishing)? Also he did a current update/epilogue but didn't mention having another child? His author bio mentioned that he has two daughters...I would've loved a little insight into his thoughts after reading so much about how he didn't want to have kids at all but reluctantly had Lily because his wife wanted to be a mother.
Grieving doesn't take away from the unpleasantness of him talking about the women around him. Besides seeing two women, 'A' and 'Z', at the same time and not telling them, he dismissed them as "Whichever Letter" when recapping the month spent without his daughter as though they were interchangeable.
An interesting note: his story isn't the first time I've read about widows/widowers tasting their spouses' ashes. I'm guessing it's more common but untalked about than people may think.
Basically, if he'd never wanted to share anything that is completely his right. But if he's taking the time to write a memoir about this time and around this subject, a fuller picture and more introspection would've been appreciated.
Quote From the Book
"I wished I would have gotten to see the powerhouse mom my wife would have become."